Arni’s Menu, Prices and Locations

Arnold “Arni” Cohen opened the doors to the flagship restaurant in 1965 at Market Square Shopping Center in Lafayette. Originally seating a little over 100 people, within 10 years Arni’s at Market Square was one of the largest and most successful restaurants in Indiana, with seating for almost 500 patrons.

The company is now owned by Arni’s 2 sons, Kurt and Brad Cohen. Arni Cohen was a board member of the Indiana Restaurant Association and was elected to the Indiana Restaurant Association Hall of Fame in 2002.

Arni’s Menu

Hot Sandwiches
Submarineham, salami, luncheon meat, cheese, onion, and lite tomato paste served on our french bread
Strombolisausage, cheese, tomato paste, onion, hot peppers served on our french bread
Garden Strombolimushroom, onion, green pepper, tomato, black olives, broccoli, cheese and tomato sauce on our french bread
Texas Bbqsausage, cheese, barbeque sauce, onion served on our french bread$6.39 - $3.79
Hot Sicilianham, salami, pepperoni, bacon bits, onions, banana peppers, mozzarella, topped with lettuce, tomato & vinaigrette dressing
Gut-Bustersausage, pepperoni, onions, jalapenos, tomato sauce, tangy barbecue sauce, all topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheeses
Italian Beefsliced roast beef, cheese, marinara sauce and onion served on our french bread
Italian Beef Bbqsliced roast beef, cheese, barbeque sauce and onions served on our french bread$6.59 - $3.99
Hot Ham And Melted Cheese$3.20
The Yacht Clubbaked fish with bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo$5.25
Pork Tenderlointopped with american cheese and garnished with banana peppers, red onion and a side of bbq sauce$5.25
Big Birdcrispy breaded chicken breast topped with bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo$5.25
Substitute Fries$0.59
Sizzling Burgers
one half pound of 100% black angus beef. served with lettuce, tomato, red onion, chips and pickle
Cheeseburgercheddar, swiss, american or pepper jack$4.99
Cajun Jack Burgerred onions, cajun spices and pepper jack cheese$5.19
Mexicali Burgerwith onions, tomato, hot jalapeno peppers and cheese$5.29
Mushroom-Swiss Burger$5.19
Smokehouse Bbq Burgerbacon, bbq sauce and cheddar cheese$5.19
Substitute Fries$0.59
Pasta And More
Deep Dish Lasagnaserved with a small tossed salad and garlic bread$6.95
Chili Spaghettia bowl full of spaghetti topped with our homemade chili, onions and cheddar cheese. served with a small tossed salad and garlic bread$7.29 - $5.79
Spaghettithat says it all except for how delicious it really is. choice of marinara or meat sauce. served with a small tossed salad and garlic bread$7.19 - $5.29
Arni's Special Clubham, turkey, bacon strips, american and swiss cheese on wheat toast with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise$5.29
Rueben A La Arnicorned beef and sauerkraut on rye, blanketed with swiss cheese and chopped tomato. served open face with thousand island dressing$5.99
Veggie Meltgarlic bread topped with mushrooms, black olives, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, broccoli and melted cheddar with a hint of italian dressing$5.29
your choice of french, bleu cheese, thousand island, ranch, celery seed, vinegar and oil, honey mustard, low calorie italian, low fat marzetti ranch & french.
Arni's Junior Saladgarden fresh chopped head lettuce with a little sliced radish and chopped green onion, cubed turkey & ham, and delicious cheese topped with croutons & our own homemade dressings$3.85
Seniora larger version of our famous junior$5.65
Mexican Taco Saladour delicious chili over a bed of lettuce, topped with cheddar cheese, jalapenos, black olives, tomatoes, green onions and sour cream.$6.35
Jr Taco Salad$5.25
Clubhouse Saladtender chunks of smoked chicken, ham, red onion, bacon, fresh veggies and hard boiled egg atop a bed of lettuce with cheddar cheese and crouton$6.49
Jr Clubhouse Salad$5.19
Southern Fried Chicken Saladchunks of deep fried chicken pieces on a bed of fresh lettuce with hard boiled eggs, chopped tomato, green onion, bacon bits and shredded cheddar. served with honey mustard dressing.$6.79
Pizza "The Best In Town
Royal Hawaiianham, pineapple, barbecue sauce and cheese$4.50 - $11.29
The Original Barbecuesausage, onion, barbecue sauce and cheese$4.50 - $11.29
Cheese7" additional toppings - $0.30 each, 10" additional toppings- $0.50 each, 14" additional toppings- $0.90 each$3.90 - $9.49
Deluxesausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion and green pepper$5.40 - $13.99
Vegetarian Deluxemushroom, onion, broccoli, green pepper, tomato and black olives with a hint of garlic$5.40 - $13.99
Barbecue Chickenmarinated chicken, onion, barbecue sauce, mozzarella and cheddar cheese$5.40 - $13.99
Pizzasausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, marinated chicken(additional charge), banana peppers, jalapeno peppers, bacon, anchovies, ham, pineapple, tomatoes, broccoli, onions
Soups And Appetizers
Cheese Garlic Breadserved with marinara sauce$2.25
Breadstickschoice of cheese or marinara sauce$3.25
Chili Nacho Supremecrispy tortilla chips with chili, cheddar, mozzarella, diced tomato, black olives, jalapeno peppers, green onions and sour cream$5.19
Chicken Wingschoose either hot & spicy buffalo wings or with a side of bbq sauce. served with celery sticks & ranch dressing$5.99
Mozzarella Wedgeslightly breaded cheese sticks, fried to a golden brown$4.99
Chicken Tender Baskethomestyle breaded chicken tenderloins, served with honey mustard and bbq sauce on a bed of fries$5.79
Loaded Friesa mountain of our delicious crispy fries, loaded with melted cheddar, bacon bits & diced green onions. served with sour cream$5.25
Homestyle Chilithick and meaty. you can eat it with a fork. add cheese and onion at no additional charge$1.99 - $3.49
Soup Of The Day$1.99 - $2.79

Visit Arni’s here for more details, hours, locations and contact information of your local Arni’s.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read previous post:
Larry’s Giant Subs Menu, Prices and Locations

The Raikes brothers, Larry & Mitch, built their first submarine sandwich shop in Jacksonville, Florida in 1982. They made their...