Bill Gray’s Menu, Prices and Locations

Bill Gray’s is a chain of restaurants based in Webster, New York that currently has 18 restaurants in the Rochester and Buffalo areas in western New York, including 3 Tap Room-style restaurants, and one tavern-style grill name Flaherty’s. Thirteen of these locations also sell Abbott’s Frozen Custard.

In 1938, Bill and Alberta Gray began selling hot dogs in Webster. Within a few years, Bill Gray’s expanded and added multiple items to its menu, including its self-proclaimed World’s Greatest Cheeseburger.

Bill Gray’s Menu

Salads, Soups & Chili
Side Salad$3.49
Garden SaladAdd chicken $2.60, add tuna $2.60$5.99
Soup$3.59 - $5.39
Chili$3.99 - $5.99
Fried Egg Sandwiches
Double Egg & Cheese$3.29
Double Egg & Cheese with Bacon, Sausage or Ham$4.19
Philly Sliced Steak Egg & Cheese$7.49
Bill's Famous Burgers
Served on a fresh baked di paolos roll with your choice of toppings.Toppings: everything: mustard, ketchup, relish, onions & bill's hot sauce. Deluxe: lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise
World's Greatest Cheeseburger$4.89
Bacon Cheeseburger$5.79
Ham & Swiss Burger$5.79
Mushroom Swiss Burger$5.79
Bacon Bleu Cheeseburger$5.79
Plate Burger$5.99
Nacho-Cheese Bacon Burger$5.79
Black Bean Burger$5.29
Honey BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger$5.79
Bubba Double Cheeseburger$7.89
Bubba Double Bacon Cheeseburger$8.79
Ground Steak Burger$4.09
Grilled Cheeseburger Melt$4.89
Veggie Burger on a Wheat Roll$5.29
Ultimate Bacon Egg Cheeseburger$6.69
Grilled Salmon Burger$5.99
Build Your Own Burger or Hot
Build Your Own Burger or HotAmerican, swiss, mozzarella or nacho cheese $0.80, grilled onions $0.40, bacon $0.90, chili $0.90, fried egg $0.90, baked beans $0.80, jalapenos $0.80, grilled peppers $0.50, peppers & onions $0.90,
Bill's Famous Hots
1/4Lb. Red or White Hot Dog$4.69
Chili-Cheese DogChili & cheese$6.39
Kraut DogJust sauerkraut$5.59
Great Plates
Hot Dog, Cheeseburger or BothServed on top of any 2 items: macaroni salad, home fries, baked beans, french fries or tater tots with your choice of toppings$9.29
Hot of The Grill
Italian Sausage$5.29
Italian Sausage with Peppers & Onions$6.19
Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese$6.59
BBQ Pulled Pork$5.69
Grilled Ham & CheeseOn a roll$5.39
Grilled Cheese & Ham MeltWhite or wheat bread$5.39
Flat Bread Pitas
Grilled Chicken Club Pita$6.49
Crispy Buffalo Chicken Pita$5.59
Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese Pita$6.59
Tuna Pita$5.29
Sauces: plain, hot, medium, honey BBQ & sal's sassy
Grilled Breast SandwichServed on a wheat roll$5.59
Crispy Fried Fillet Sandwich$5.59
Crispy Fried Buffalo Fillet Sandwich$5.59
Chicken Tenders (Plain or Buffalo) - 5pc$7.29
Chicken Tenders (Plain or Buffalo) - 10pc$13.99
Chicken Tenders (Plain or Buffalo) - 15pc$20.69
Boneless Wings$7.39 - $13.99
Traditional Bar Wings - 5pc$5.59
Traditional Bar Wings - 10pc$10.99
Traditional Bar Wings - 20pc$21.69
Traditional Bar Wings - 30pc$31.99
Hooked on Seafood
Dinners: served with choice of any two sides: french fries, sweet potato fries, cole slaw, macaroni salad, side salad or baked beans. (Mashed potatoes - friday only)
Bill's Famous Haddock Fish Fry$11.99
Mini Haddock Fish Fry$10.29
1/2Lb Clam Strip Dinner$10.29
Shrimp Dinners$11.99 - $17.99
Sandwiches & Baskets
Tuna Melt$5.29
Clam Roll$5.09
1/2Lb Clam Strip Basket$6.79
Battered Popcorn Shrimp Basket$9.99
Haddock Fish Sandwich$7.29
Shrimp Baskets$9.99 - $15.99
Grilled Salmon Burger$5.99
Seafood PlatterMini haddock, clams, shrimp, french fries & coleslaw$15.99
Side Orders
French Fries$3.49 - $6.79
Tater Tots$3.49 - $6.79
Curly Fries$3.49 - $6.79
Home Fries$3.49 - $6.79
Sweet Potato Fries$3.99 - $7.79
Onion Rings$3.99 - $7.79
Chili Cheese Fries$5.19
Mac & Cheese$2.99
Mac Salad, Cole Slaw, Baked Beans$2.89
Mozzarella Sticks (3)$3.79
Mozzarella Sticks (6)$7.29
Mozzarella Sticks (9)$10.59
Pizza Logs (2)$3.39
Pizza Logs (4)$6.39
Pizza Logs (8)$12.49
Mushrooms$4.19 - $7.89
Appetizer SamplerPizza logs, mozzarella sticks, boneless wings & onion rings$11.99
Kids Meals
Served with choice of french fries, curly fries or fruit cup & choice of small beverage, slushie, milk or juice
Hot Dog$5.69
Grilled Cheese$4.99
Chicken Tenders$5.99
Chicken Wings$5.99
Mozzarella Sticks$5.99
Pizza Logs$5.99
Mac & Cheese$5.79
Frozen Custard
Toppings: sprinkles $0.69, peanuts $0.89, chopped snickers, peanut butter cups or oreos $0.89
Cone, Dish - Vanilla or Chocolate$2.78 - $4.40
Classic Sundaes
Hot Fudge$5.55
Peanut Butter Cup$5.55
Strawberry Fudge$5.55
Pepsi Products$2.19 - $2.89
Energy Drinks$2.99
Gatorade, G2$2.39
Slushies$2.29 - $3.79
Bottled Water$1.29
Coffee, Tea$1.69 - $2.19
Hot Chocolate$1.69 - $2.19
Milkshakes & Floats$3.49 - $6.39

Visit Bill Gray’s here for more details, hours, locations and contact information of your local Bill Gray’s.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read previous post:
Sapporo Menu, Prices and Locations

Sapporo Japanese Restaurant, voted #1 Best Sushi Restaurant in Louisville, is consistently rated as one of Louisville’s popular Japanese restaurants....