Goodfella’s Menu, Prices and Locations

Welcome to The Original Goodfella’s Established 1992 at 1718 Hylan Blvd Staten Island Ny where it all started, home to the Best Pizza in New York and the World!

Since I was a little boy I always loved pizza. Growing up in Brooklyn having some of the best pizzas at places like Patsies, Totonno’s and all the other great family pizza places my love and passion for pizza began. My goal was to make nothing but the best pizza I could. With that goal in mind, and in our first year of business, I created the Vodka Pizza, a gourmet pizza unlike any other, that won me the prestigious honor of being Voted America’s Best Pizza! at The Jacob Javits Center, New York City International Hotel and Restaurant show.

Goodfella’s Menu

BBQ, Teriyaki, Buffalo, Garlic Wings(10 Pcs).$8.99
Fired Mozzarella Cheese Sticks$4.95
Garlic Bread With Cheese$2.75
Garlic Bread$1.75
Pepperoni, Spinach Pinwheel$1.25
Garlic Knots6 Pcs.$1.75
All salads served with house, blue cheese, ranch dressing.
Goodfella's Salad(W/ cubes of ham, salami, provolone).$5.50
Chef's Salad(W/ ham, salami, capicola, provolone rolls).$5.50
Grilled, Breaded Chicken Salad$6.50
Chicken Cesear Salad$6.95
Cesear Salad$5.50
Tossed Salad$2.50
Homemade pastas served with a bakery fresh plain, garlic knots & onion bread.
Spaghetti W/ MeatballsMeat sauce, sausage, mushrooms, marinara.$5.95
Spaghetti W/ Garlic & Olive Oil$6.95
Spaghetti W/ Butter & Romano Cheese$6.95
Ziti W/ MeatballsMeat sauce, sausage, mushrooms, marinara.$5.95
Baked Ziti$6.95
Ziti Baked W/ Meat Sauce & Mozzarella$6.95
Ziti Al Vodka W/ Pink SauceHot or mild.$6.95
Linguine W/ Red Or White Clam Sauce$6.95
Linguine Primavera W/ Pink Sauce(Green peas, mushrooms, carrots, fresh tomatoes).$6.95
Stuffed Shells$6.95
Cheese Ravioli$6.95
Ravioli W/ Pesto Sauce Or Pink Sauce$6.95
Fettuccine AlfredoAdd chicken for $2.99.$6.95
Cheese Tortellini W/ Pink Sauce$6.95
Sampler Dish$8.25
Goodfella's SpecialSpaghetti w/ meatballs, sausage & meat sauce.$8.95
Pepperoni, Meat Lovers Stuffed Slice$2.95
Cheese SliceAdd a topping $0.50.$1.75
Goodfella’s Specialty PizzaPepperoni, sausage, canadian bacon, hamburger, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions, (jalapenos, anchovies upon request).$14.95 - $15.95
Veggie Lovers PizzaMushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions, tomatoes.$14.95 - $15.95
Hawaiian PizzaCanadian bacon, pineapple.$14.95 - $15.95
Alfredo PizzaAlfredo sauce and mozzarella.$14.95 - $15.95
White PizzaRicotta, mozzarella, parmesan and fresh garlic.$14.95 - $15.95
Lasagna PizzaGround beef, ricotta, fresh garlic, roasted red peppers.$14.95
Spinach StuffedSpinach, mushrooms, onions and mozzarella.$21.95 - $22.95
Meat Lovers Stuffed PizzaPepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mozzarella, onions, green peppers and fresh garlic w/ side of marinara sauce.$22.95 - $23.95
Pepperoni, Chicken Stuffed PizzaPepperoni, chicken, mozzarella w/ side of marinara sauce.$21.95 - $22.95
Deep Dish Sicilian PizzaAdditional topping $1.50 each.$12.95
Cheese PizzaAdditional topping $1.50 each for pepperoni, sausage, canadian bacon, hamburger, mushrooms, sauteed spinach, green peppers, black olives, onions, pineapple, jalapenos, anchovies, chicken $2.50.$10.50 - $11.50
Calzone, Stromboli
StromboliAll meats extra topping $0.50.$5.95
CalzoneAll cheese choice of one topping upon request extra topping $0.50.$5.50
Cold Subs
Footlong. All cold sandwiches come with lettuce, tomoto, black olives, and our own special dressing.
The Works$6.25
Salami Provolone$5.95
Cappicolla, Provolone$5.95
Ham, Provolone$5.95
Meatball Parmigiana$5.95
Sausage Parmigiana$5.95
Sausage & Pepper$5.95
Chicken Parmigiana$6.25
Eggplant Parmigiana$6.25
Philly Cheese Steak$6.25
Chicken Parmigiana$8.50
Eggplant Parmigia$8.50
Chicken MarsalaChicken breast sauteed w/ mushrooms and marsala wine.$8.50
Chicken PiccataChicken breast sauteed w/ white wine, lemmon butter, capers.$8.50
Chicken CacciatoreChicken breast sauteed w/ mushrooms, green bell peppers and onions in marinara sauce.$8.50
Chicken CarciofiChicken breast sauteed w/ mushrooms, artichokes in lemon butter or pink sauce.$8.50
Grilled Chicken PrimaveraChicken breast sauteed w/ green peas, carrots and mushrooms, fresh tomatoes w/ linguine.$8.50
Grilled Chicken Al PestoChicken breast sauteed in green basil sauce a touch of alfredo, fresh tomatoes w/ linguine.$8.50
Grilled Chicken Al VodkaHot or mild. Chicken breast sauteed w/ fresh tomatoes, shallots, garlic, basil, vodka in pink sauce w/ ziti.$8.50
Chicken Fettuccini AlfredoChicken breast sauteed w/ alfredo sauce.$8.50
Chicken FranceseChicken breast in egg batter sauteed w/ garlic, lemmon butter and white wine w/ spaghetti.$8.50
Eggplant RollatiniBreaded eggplant rolls stuffed w/ ricotta, spinach in marinara sauce and topped w/ mozzarella.$8.50
Goodfella's Sides
Meatballs, Sausage$2.00
Alfredo Sauce, Chicken Breast$2.95
Chicken Breast$2.75
Extra Ranch, Blue Cheese$0.50
Desserts And Soft Drink
Strawberry, Chocolate, Plain Cheesecake$2.95
Chocolate, Plain Cannoli$2.95
Fountain DrinkCoke, diet coke, sprite, dr pepper, orange, pink lemonade, iced tea.$1.60
2 Ltrs Bottle Of SodaCoke, diet coke, sprite, dr pepper, diet dr pepper.$2.75
Cans Of SodaCoke, dr pepper, diet dr pepper.$1.00
Bottle Of Water$1.00

Visit Goodfella’s here for more details, hours, locations and contact information of your local Goodfella’s.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read previous post:
George’s Menu, Prices and Locations

George’s Market at Dreshertown, its owners, management, and all its staff, pledge to provide all its customers with the highest...