Pinchers Menu, Prices and Locations

Pinchers Crab Shack opened its first restaurant in a 1,500 square-foot space nestled inside a strip mall in Bonita Springs.The year was 1997 and owner Tony Phelan was determined to give Southwest Florida something it lacked – the freshest seafood served in a fun, down-to-earth atmosphere.The concept of the six table, 12 employee restaurant was simple: Make it look like an old seafood shack you’d find resting along the Gulf coast, yet place it miles from water. In essence, bring the Gulf of Mexico to where the bulk of the population lived.

Pinchers Menu

Pinchers Previews
Fried Calamaricousin guido's favorite snack, freshly breaded & deep fried to a golden brown$6.99
Smoked Fish Dipbilly jack jim bob claims this recipe has been passed on for generations. Fresh fish smoked just right and mixed with those secret spices to share with your favorite crackers and saltines, too$5.99
Boatload of Musselstender mussels sauteed in white wine & garlic butter with parmesan cheese. Served with our fresh garlic bread bon appetite!$8.99
Hushpuppiessouthern style cornmeal, buttermilk and sweet onions fried into a tasty treat.$5.99
Coconut Shrimpfresh six-pack of shrimp rolled in coconut and cooked to a golden brown. A true tropical tradition.$7.99
Beach Breadgiant garlic bread loaf loaded with tomato, blue cheese dressing, beach spices, mozzarella, etc...$6.99
Crap Dipheaping lumped concoction of a variety of crabs in a creamy and slightly zesty blend. Served with your favorite crackers and saltines.$8.99
Conch Frittersthose renowned key west critter fritters devoured by uncle ernie at numerous events.$6.99
Stuffed Deviled Crabnothing devilish here. A pair of crabs stuffed with our concoction of crab meat, special spices and other ingredients known only to a select few$4.99
Mozzarella Cheese Sticksthese crowd pleasers make a great addition to any menu item.. Served with our special marinara sauce for dipping. They'll melt in your mouth.$5.99
Buffalo Shrimpa new twist to an old favorite. Freshly breaded shrimp deep- fried & tossed in our ultimate wing sauce of your pleasure with blue cheese & celery wimpy-medium-serious-or painfully pinching.$10.99
The Soup Pot
Homemade Clam ChowderNew England style-creamy, white and pure a favorite developed by those blue blood pinchers of the northeastestern coast.$3.49 - $5.99
Crab & Corn Chowderpinchers own famous cream based beauty chock full of lump crab, corn and a pinch a pepper to bring a little zing.$3.99 - $6.99
Chicken Sausage Gumboway down in the bayou the creole chefs chased down chicken, cut up andouille sausage and made their world famous roux for this southern classic. Have the urge for something on the lighter side. Enjoy$7.99
Maryland Style Blue Crabs
subject to local availability. If we can't get it. You can't have it. Add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99. Steamed in old bay and served with lots of towels at market price (subject to availability)
Jus One (1)
By the Order (6)
By the Dozen (12)
For the Serious Crab Lovers (24)
Pinchers Fish Platters
add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99. For the fish lover... choose one of our fresh catches grilled, broiled or blackened. Served with two side bar choices.
Yellowfin Tuna$11.99
Mahi Mahi$11.99
Pinchers Pastas
all served over angel hair pasta with garlic bread & topped with parmesan cheese. Add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99
Clam Pepper Scampihearty clams sauteed in garlic butter & wine, simmered in a combination of fresh red, green, and yellow peppers with our secret family spices, MMM-mmmmm!$12.99
Mussels Marinaraa "boatload" of mussels simmered in our renowned marinara sauce with the freshest of ingredients...a must for the mussel lover...molto buono!$11.99
Chicken Parmesana new flare to a traditional favorite. A Bonless chicken breast deep fried or gilled, topped with our special marinara sauce and freshly grated cheese.$10.99
Shrimp Marinaragulf shrimp simmered in our renowned marinara sauce with the freshest of ingredients to create an incredible experience. ooh! la! la!$11.99
Shrimp Scampia generous amount of gulf shrimp sauteed in lots of garlic butter & wine with our secret family spices. Guaranteed to ward off any vampires!$11.99
Pinchers Crab Shack
add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99. A full pound and a half of crabs... pick your favorite... Served with your choice of two items from the side bar
King Crab$39.99
Snow Crab$24.99
Dungeness Crab$24.99
Pinchers off the Bone Ribs
add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99
Pinchers off the Bone Ribstwo pounds of st. louie style fall-off-the-bone ribs for all you BBQ connoisseurs. Wait 'til you taste our homemade BBQ sauce. Yee! hah! served with your choice of two sides$18.99
Pinchers Caesar Salad
now some of us pinchers still need our greens... so we've created the ultimate salads. Fresh romaine & greens tossed with our soon to be famous dressing & croutons. (We'll even include those little fishies on request). Served with warm garlic brea
Pinchers Caesar Salador top it with chicken, mahi mahi, salmon, shrimp, grouper or tuna for $11.99. Available grilled blackened, or broiled.$7.99 - $5.99
Sandwiches by Land Or by Sea
all of the following served with two side bar choices and topped with lettuce & tomato. American or swiss cheese can be added for $0.69. Add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99. There is a risk associated to the consumption of hems prepared le
Soft Shell Crab Po Boysoft shell crab fried to a golden brown & served on a fresh hoagie topped with a side of cajun mayonnaise.$12.99
The Great Grouper Sandwichfresh florida grouper grilled, broiled blackened, or lightly breaded & fried. Served on a toasted roll.$12.99
Crab Cake Sandwichour famous crab cake served on a toasted bun with a side of stone mustard.$10.99
Grilled Mahi Mahi Sandwicha grilled, blackened, or broiled mahi mahi fillet served on a fresh hoagie roll.$12.99
Shrimp Po Boydeep fried shrimp on a toasted hoagie with a side of cajun mayo.$12.99
Pinchers Steak Sandwicha tender 1/2 lb. strip steak served on a roll.$10.99
Oyster Po Boydeep fried select oysters on a toasted hoagie with a side of cajun mayo.$12.99
Tuna Salad Sandwichour freshly made tuna salad served on a fresh bun.$7.99
Pincher Burgerhere's the beef. 100% black angus one half pound beauty cooked to your liking.$7.99
Pinchers Buffalo Poultry Picka deep fried chicken breast coated in our awesome wing sauce and served on a toasted bun with bleu cheese dressing.$7.99
The Pincher Doga quarter pound grilled all beef hot dog. Served with relish & onions on request.$6.79
Pinchers Poultry Picka marinated grilled chicken breast on a toasted bun. Try our "house favorite" complete with BBQ sauce & swiss for $0.99 extra.$7.99
Pinchers Side Bar
Fresh Cut French Fries (Cut to Order)$2.99
Baked Beans$1.99
Fresh Cole Slaw$1.99
Fresh Florida Corn on the Cob (In Season)$1.99
Pasta Salad$1.99
Potato Salad$1.99
Fresh Cut Veggies$2.99
Pinchers Garlic Bread$1.99
Pinchers House Specialties
subject to local availability. If we can't get it. You can't have it. Add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99
Soft Shelled Crabstwo softshells sauteed in garlic butter or fried & served with cole slaw. No fuss eat the whole thing!
Garlic & Butter Blue Crab Clustersour pinchers family specialty clusters of the freshest blue crab sauteed in fresh garlic-oh! la! la!$9.99 - $39.99
Spiced Garlic & Butter Blue Crab Clustersclusters of the garlic blue crab sauteed in our secret spices... Yeahhh baby!!$9.99 - $39.99
Crab Cakesthose folks from maryland love 'em! 100% real blue crab meat served with slaw.$8.99 - $16.99
Pincher Clawsblue crab claws sauteed in white wine & garlic butter with parmesan cheese just like our mussels. Served with our fresh garlic bread.$10.99
Pinchers Famous Fish & Chips
add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99
Fish & Chipsa generous portion of fried fish, fresh cut French fries, and creamy cole slaw.$9.99
Pinchers Basket Case
these favorites are served with your choice of two items from the side bar. Add soup or house salad or 1/2 caesar for $2.99
Fresh New England Fried Flounder$12.99
Fresh Florida Frog Legs(fried/sauteed)$11.99
Fresh Florida Grouper Basket(fried/grilled/broiled/blackened)$12.99
Fried Shrimp Basket$11.99
Shrimp Basket(grilled/BBQ)$12.99
Fried Calamari Basket$10.99
Fried Clam Strip Basket$11.99
Fried Oyster Basket$12.99
Scallop Basket(fried/broiled)$14.99
Chicken Finger Basket(buffalo style with bleu cheese $0.69 extra)$9.99
Double Your Funadd a second basket choice to any of the above - add groups, scallops, shrimp, clam strips, oysters, calamari, chicken$8.99
Try the Pincher Platter For Two(with this platter select 3 different basket case items & 3 side bar choices)$29.99
Pinchers Sweet Side
Homemade Key Lime Pie Topped with Whipped Cream$3.99
Dar to Indulge in...The Chocolate Crab..Mmmmmrich chocolate ice cream chewy chocolate brownie pieces chocolate syrup$4.99
The Pinchers Store
Can Coolers$2.99
Crabwear: T's$14.99
Snookie: T's$16.99
Fat Tuesday: T's$16.99
Fishing Team: T's$16.99
Fishing Team: Tanks$16.99
Pinchers World Famous Hot Sauceavailable in: one pepper & three pepper$4.95
Raw Bar - Peel & Eat Shrimp
order these steamed shrimp hot or cold
Peel & Eat Shrimp$9.99 - $17.99
Raw Bar - Clams
there will be no clamming up about these pincher pleasers... We'll serve these middle necks as fresh as they come on the half shell or just steamed 'til they smile. Ask about our happy hour specials 2 for 1 draft beer. Specials on clams, oysters, shrimp &
Clams$5.99 - $10.99
Raw Bar - Stone Crab Claws
try just two of these seasonal treats we'll serve 'em hot or cold... your choice! (available Oct. 15 - May 15)
Stone Crab Claws
Raw Bar - Oysters
these bad boys have been known by generations for their ability to make the meek into monsters. Served just naked... or already steamy. There is a risk associated to the consumption of raw oysters if you have certain ailments. Please consult a physician b
Oysters$5.99 - $10.99
Raw Bar - Jumbo Wings
created by those poultry pinchers (the other side of the family) lightly breaded or just naked... choice of wimpy, medium, serious, painfully pinching (hottest in town), tony's three pepper sauce (uniquely flavored medium spice green and good!), teriyaki
Jumbo Wings an Order (10)$6.99
Jumbo Wings an Adorer (20)$11.99
Jumbo Wings a Partier (50)$23.99

Visit Pinchers here for more details, hours, locations and contact information of your local Pinchers.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read previous post:
Bella Luna Menu, Prices and Locations

A fixture on Columbus, Bella Luna offers you the quintessential Italian dining experience. Our familial service will always make you...