Pizza My Heart Menu, Prices and Locations

We were founded in 1981.  Appropriately, that was the year the Rolling Stones had a monster hit with Start Me Up, And, like Mick Jagger, we’re both going strong several decades later.  The first restaurant was right on Capitola Beach. It’s not much larger than the average bedroom, but that tiny Capitola restaurant has become a landmark for surfers and beach goers alike.  Summer days often see the line for pizza reach nearly a block long. We’re proud to say pizza and surf now go together in Capitola like hot dogs and baseball.

Pizza My Heart Menu

Appetizers & Salads
Bread StixOur own bread stix with olive oil & cheese. Ask for ranch dressing or pizza sauce$5.75
Buffalo Wings8 Fiery wings. Ask for ranch or blue cheese.$7.25
Greek SaladRomaine lettuce, onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese, artichokes & tomatoes$3.75
Seasonal GreensMixed baby greens, carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes & broccoli$3.75
Classic CaesarRomaine lettuce, garlic croutons, parmesan & a great classic caesar dressing$4.75
Classic Caesar with ChickenRomaine lettuce, garlic croutons, parmesan & a great classic caesar dressing$5.75
Chicken WalnutMixed baby greens, candied walnuts, chicken, gorgonzola with our own balsamic dressing$5.75
Large Salads
Serves 10 Surfers Greek Salad$24.00
Seasonal Greens$24.00
Classic Caesar$30.00
Classic Caesar with Chicken$36.00
Chicken Walnut$36.00
Design Your Own Pizza
Cheese$11.50 - $19.75
1 Topping$13.00 - $21.75
2 Toppings$14.50 - $23.75
3 Toppings$16.00 - $25.75
4 Toppings$17.50 - $27.75
Canadian Bacon
Sundried Tomatoes
Fresh Serrano Chiles
Cherry Tomatoes
Roasted Red Peppers
Fresh Sage
Portobello Mushrooms
Award Winning Pizzas
Big Sur40 Cloves of roasted garlic, organic tomato pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, portobello mushrooms & green onions.$17.50 - $27.75
Virgin CreekFresh basil, garlic, ricotta & roma tomatoes best traditional pizza$17.50 - $27.75
Watsonville AppleGreen apple slices, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green onions, gorgonzola & garlic. No red sauce$17.50 - $27.75
Little Sur40 Cloves of roasted garlic, organic tomato pizza sauce, roasted red peppers, portobella mushrooms, green onions, cherry tomatoes & herbs$17.50 - $27.75
Fort PointLight tomato & pesto sauce with roma tomatoes, chicken, ricotta, sausage, artichoke, basil & herbs.$17.50 - $27.75
Specialty Pizzas with Meat
Maverick'sA carnivore's delight. Pepperoni, sausage, salami, & canadian bacon$17.50 - $27.75
Wingnut'sPepperoni, red onions, & mushrooms. Named after a favorite customer from capitola.$14.50 - $23.75
Cowell's ComboPepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms, onions & bells$17.50 - $27.75
DavenportSausage, spinach, garlic, mushrooms & onions$17.50 - $27.75
The LanePesto, sausage, & roma tomatoes$16.00 - $25.75
Maui WowieCanadian bacon & pineapple$14.50 - $23.75
Sunset BeachCanadian bacon, bacon, red onions, bells & pineapple$17.50 - $27.75
D'Lex Chicken & BaconChicken, bacon, mushrooms, garlic, green onions in a white sauce.$17.50 - $27.75
RockawayBBQ sauce, chicken, red onion, cilantro$16.00 - $25.75
Depot HillSundried tomatoes, pesto & chicken$17.50 - $27.75
Pleasure PointGarlic, roma tomatoes, spinach & chicken$17.50 - $27.75
Todos SantosChicken, Sausage, Red Onions, Serranos & Rancholula Sauce$16.00 - $25.75
Steamer'sOur famous clams & garlic$14.50 - $23.75
Ano NuevoSausage, clams & garlic$16.00 - $25.75
Figgy PiggyBacon, black figs, fresh sage & feta$17.50 - $27.50
San AndreasPastrami, pepperoncini, gourmet mustard$17.50 - $27.50
Vegetarian Specialty Pizzas
PestoMade with basil, garlic, parmesan & walnuts$14.50 - $23.70
The ClassicFresh basil, garlic & roma tomatoes$14.50 - $23.70
Prima PizzaRoma tomatoes, feta, olives & parmesan$14.50 - $23.70
ManresaWhite pizza with fresh basil, garlic, romas & ricotta$16.00 - $25.75
Santa CruzSpinach, mushrooms & onions$16.00 - $25.75
Natural BridgesPesto, ricotta & romas. Without red sauce$16.00 - $25.75
Sand DollarGarlic, spinach, mushrooms & roma tomatoes$16.00 - $25.75
AsilomarTomatoes, olives, garlic, onions, mushrooms & bells$17.50 - $27.75
The HookTomatoes, olives, onions, bells, mushrooms, artichoke & parmesan$17.50 - $27.75
Linda MarSpinach, garlic, artichokes, broccoli, olives & romas$17.50 - $27.75
38th Ave SpecialSpinach, artichoke, sundried tomatoes & feta cheese$17.50 - $27.75
Slices & Drinks
Available in restaurant only, or delivery with full size pizza orders
Chicken & Bacon$4.00
Pepperoni & Sausage$4.00
The Big SurPepperoni, sausage, portobello, garlic$4.00
Maui WowieHam & pineapple$3.75
Super Veggie$4.00
PestoBasil, garlic, walnuts & parmesan$3.75
PrimaTomatoes, olives & feta$3.75
Seasonal Greens, Slice & SodaMixed baby greens, carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes & broccoli$7.75
Caesar Salad, Slice & SodaHomemade caesar dressing, cheese & croutons$8.75
Greek Salad, Slice & SodaLettuce, feta, olives & tomatoes$7.75
Chicken Walnut Salad, Slice & SodaLettuce, chicken, walnuts & gorgonzola$9.75
Fountain Soda Coke$2.00
Diet Coke$2.00
Sprite (20 oz)$2.00
Bottled Soda$2.25
Vitamin Water$2.25
Dasani Water$1.50

Visit Pizza My Heart here for more details, hours, locations and contact information of your local Pizza My Heart.

Leave a Comment

Read previous post:
Pho Saigon Menu, Prices and Locations

Located in and around Philadelphia. Our patrons come from far and wide to taste our delicious dishes. We welcome you...